Image

Eddie & Sam's NY Pizza

WHERE TAMPA MEETS

NEW YORK

For over two decades, we’ve brought the authentic taste of New York pizza to the heart of downtown Tampa. At Eddie & Sam's N.Y. Pizza, our pizza is known for its wide, foldable slices and that perfect thin, crispy crust. The secret? We use authentic New York water in our dough, bringing a piece of the Big Apple straight to every slice we make. It’s our way of delivering the real New York pizza experience to Florida.


Welcome to Eddie & Sam's Pizza!

View Menu

OUR FAMOUS NEW YORK PIZZA

  • Image

    Pepperoni & Cheese Pizza

    Enjoy our all day classic peperoni and cheese pizza. Thin crust topped with tomato sauce, mozzarella cheese, and slices of pepperoni.

    Order Now
  • Image

    Buffalo Chicken Pizza

    Cheese topped with diced cut breaded chicken breast mixed with our homemade buffalo sauce, topped with ranch dressing, no base sauce.

    Order Now
  • Image

    Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

    Savor every bite with a ranch base, gooey cheese, crispy chicken breast, and smoky bacon on top.


    Order Now
1 / 2
Image

COME AND GET IT

AUTHENTIC NEW YORK PIZZA,

RIGHT IN TAMPA

What sets us apart?

We use New York water to craft every batch of dough, ensuring every slice is as close to NYC perfection as you can get. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite during lunch, feeding a crowd with one of our XXL pies, or watching the game with friends, we are your go-to spot for great pizza, wings and more. During the day, we’re buzzing with the energy of the downtown crowd, and by night, Eddie & Sam's transforms into the go-to spot for Tampa’s vibrant nightlife. Stop by on a Friday or Saturday, and you'll find a lively scene with plenty of pizza to go around.

About Us
Image

FROM SLICES TO 28" PIES

WE'VE GOT YOUR PIZZA CRAVINGS COVERED

Whether you're grabbing a quick slice on the go or feeding a crowd with our massive XXL pizzas, we’ve got the perfect pizza for any occasion. At Eddie & Sam’s, you’ll always find a pizza that's right for your appetite.

Order Now

  • Image

    GET INTO OUR LOYALTY PROGRAM

    Sign up for our loyalty program—the more you enjoy our pizza, the more rewards come your way!

    Rewards
  • Image

    GET A GIFT CARD

    Share the gift of authentic pizza or delicious wings with your friends and family. Treat your loved ones to the flavors you enjoy most.

    Gift Cards
Image

BEST NEW YORK STYLE PIZZA IN TAMPA BAY

At Eddie & Sam’s, we’re more than just a pizza place—we’re a slice of New York right here in Tampa. With fresh ingredients, authentic recipes, and a love for pizza that goes back decades, discover what makes our pizza so special.

View Menu

Reviews

  • Absolutely the best NYC style pizza in the Tampa Bay area. There are other very good choices, but this place is hands down the best. Once you figure out how to order and how to pay it's easy. Delicious pizza every time!

    Mark W.

  • Absolutely the BEST GLUTEN FREE pizza I have had to date so the fact that it's NEW YORK pizza just makes it that much better!! I highly recommend it.

    Juice

  • As always Eddie & Sam’s pizza some of the best NY pizza I have ever had outside NY. Service is always good there. They import water from NY to make it authentic NY pizza. Beside cheese pizza I love their Parmesan eggplant pizza.

    Esfaque A.

1 / 2